Representation in Immigration Court: A Closer Look

Representation in Immigration Court: A Closer Look

For immigration-related questions, call us at (619) 746-8879

The immigration court system in the United States is notoriously complex and challenging, especially for individuals who do not have legal representation. The system is plagued by several rudimentary aspects that make it difficult for immigrants to navigate and secure their rights.

One of the most fundamental problems is the lack of access to legal representation. A study by the American Bar Association found that only 37% of immigrants in immigration court have legal representation. This is due to a number of factors, including the high cost of legal services, the complex and time-consuming nature of immigration cases, and the language barrier.

Without legal representation, immigrants are at a significant disadvantage in immigration court. They may not understand the legal process, their rights, or the evidence against them, and may also have difficulty communicating with the judge and other parties involved in the case.

For these reasons, having appropriate legal representation in immigration court is advised and beneficial.

The right to representation

Immigrants facing removal proceedings in immigration courts have a number of rights related to legal representation, which are enshrined in the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) and have been further clarified by federal courts.

One of the most important rights is the right to be represented by an attorney of their choice. This right is guaranteed by the INA, which states that “no person shall be under any penalty in a proceeding before an immigration judge or other officer of the Department of Justice by reason of failure to be represented by an attorney.”

Immigrants are no exception; they also have the right to have their case heard by an immigration judge who is impartial and unbiased. This right is protected by the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.

In addition, immigrants have the right to be informed of their legal rights and options. This includes the right to be informed of the possibility of obtaining free or low-cost legal assistance.

Can you get a government-appointed counsel on immigration cases?

Despite these rights, immigrants facing removal proceedings are not guaranteed government-appointed counsel. This is because immigration proceedings are considered civil, not criminal. In criminal proceedings, defendants have a Sixth Amendment right to government-appointed counsel if they cannot afford to hire their own attorney. However, this right does not extend to immigration proceedings.

As a result, immigrants who are not represented are more likely to be deported, even if they have a valid claim to remain in the United States. They are also more likely to be detained in immigration detention centers, which can be dangerous and inhumane.

But, why are immigration attorneys so important in these cases? Immigration lawyers play a vital role in immigration court hearings. They help immigrants to understand their rights and options, prepare their cases, and represent them before the judge.

Here are some of the specific tasks that attorneys perform during immigration court hearings:

• Explain the law and the immigration process to their clients. Immigrants may not be familiar with US immigration law or the immigration court process. Attorneys can help their clients to understand their rights and options and to prepare for their hearings.
• Gather and present evidence. Attorneys can help clients gather and present evidence to support their cases. This may include evidence of eligibility for immigration relief, such as asylum or refugee status, or evidence of hardship that would be caused by deportation.
• Examine witnesses. Attorneys can cross-examine witnesses for the government and present their witnesses. This is important for challenging the government’s case and presenting the immigrant’s best side.
• Make legal arguments. Attorneys can make legal arguments to the judge on behalf of their clients. This may include arguments about the interpretation of the law, the admissibility of evidence, or the applicability of immigration relief.

Attorneys also play an essential role in advising immigrants about their cases and helping them to make informed decisions. For example, an attorney may advise an immigrant about whether to apply for a particular type of immigration relief or whether to appeal a negative decision by the immigration judge.

Impact of legal representation

Studies have shown that immigrants who are represented by attorneys are more likely to win their deportation cases. A study by the American Immigration Council found that immigrants with attorneys were five times more likely to obtain legal relief than those without attorneys. Also, it has been determined that immigrants who were detained and had attorneys were ten-and-a-half times more likely to succeed than detained immigrants without attorneys.

We also know that representation is especially important for vulnerable immigrants, such as unaccompanied minors and people with disabilities. These immigrants may have difficulty navigating the immigration court system on their own and may not be able to represent themselves effectively in court. This is where attorneys are beneficial as they can provide these immigrants with the support and representation they need to protect their rights and to remain in the United States.

Can you self-represent in immigration court?

Immigration law is complex and ever-changing, and immigrants who represent themselves must be able to understand and apply the law to their cases. They must also be familiar with the immigration court process and the evidence needed to win a case.

In addition to the legal complexities, immigrants who decide to go with self-representation must also be able to communicate effectively with the judge and other parties involved in the case. This may be difficult for immigrants who do not speak English fluently or are unfamiliar with the legal system.

However, if you decide to represent yourself in immigration court, here are some tips you can follow:

• Educate yourself about immigration law and the immigration court process. There are a number of resources available to help you learn about immigration law, including the American Immigration Council website and the website of the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR).
• Gather as much evidence as possible to support your case. This may include evidence of eligibility for immigration relief, such as asylum or refugee status, or evidence of hardship that would be caused by deportation.
• Practice what you are going to say in court. This will help you to feel more confident and to avoid making mistakes.
• Consider hiring an attorney to represent you, at least for part of your case. An attorney can help you to understand the law, develop a case strategy, and prepare for court.

Even if you decide to represent yourself in immigration court, it is important to seek legal advice from an attorney whenever possible. An attorney can help you to avoid making mistakes and to protect your rights.

Representation in immigration court is essential

For immigrants who want to protect their rights and remain in the United States, having appropriate representation in immigration court is vital to succeed. Immigrants who are represented by attorneys are more likely to win their deportation cases and obtain legal relief.

In San Diego, California, you can count on Kannan Law to guide you and represent you in immigration court. Contact us for more!